Skip to main content

A Church, 17 Apartments, and the Meaning of "Construction"

A A A

Article

A neighborhood church stood for more than 100 years. Then an affordable housing developer bought it.

Background of DevNW v. Bureau of Labor and Industries

The developer, DevNW, worked with the congregation and the neighbors on a plan that would keep the church’s aesthetics, but would remove nearly everything inside it. It kept the foundation, the exterior walls, and certain exterior windows. Within the shell, it built 17 affordable apartments.

Whether those apartments had to be built at prevailing wages went to the Oregon Court of Appeals. On September 16, 2026, a divided panel said the exemption for affordable housing under ORS 279C.810(2)(d) applied. DevNW v. Bureau of Labor and Industries, 353 Or App 25 (2026).

Oregon's prevailing wage law exempts “[p]rojects for residential construction that are privately owned and that predominantly provide affordable housing.” ORS 279C.810(2)(d). The parties agreed DevNW's project was a public work, so the dispute turned on whether this qualified as a “residential construction” project.

BOLI argued that the exemption reaches the initial construction of housing. A church that already stood on the site, BOLI reasoned, took the project outside that category. The Court of Appeals disagreed.

The Court of Appeals' Decision

In reaching its decision, the Court accepted that the legislature meant "initial construction" of housing. But it reasoned DevNW had done exactly that. No housing stood on the lot before. DevNW built the internal walls, kitchens, and bathrooms that created it. Repurposing the existing church into housing was the "initial construction" of housing “because it was building affordable residential housing on property where none previously existed.”

Implications of DevNW v. Bureau of Labor and Industries

This decision gives developers, general contractors, and subcontractors a clearer way to think about conversions in the affordable housing sector. What matters is the finished project. If the finished project is affordable housing, reusing existing foundation, walls, or windows does not disqualify the project from the exemption from prevailing wages.

This decision has practical effects on affordable housing projects. Wage obligations drive labor cost. Labor cost drives the bid. On a conversion that involves public funds, parties should find out early whether the ORS 279C.810(2)(d) exemption applies. Developers weighing adaptive reuse of churches, schools, or commercial buildings now have a published appellate decision to cite when seeking a prevailing wage exemption. 

If you have questions about prevailing wage exemptions for adaptive reuse affordable housing projects, please contact the Miller Nash construction team. 

This article is provided for informational purposes only—it does not constitute legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship between the firm and the reader. Readers should consult legal counsel before taking action relating to the subject matter of this article.

  Edit this post